The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch – Readalong Review

Posted January 6, 2016 by Nicole @ Feed Your Fiction Addiction in Reviews / 26 Comments

The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch – Readalong ReviewThe Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch
Series: Gentleman Bastard
Published by Bantam on July, 2006
Genres: Epic, Fantasy
Pages: 499
Source: Purchased
My content rating: Adult (Some adult language and themes, Violence)
My rating:
4 Stars

In this stunning debut, author Scott Lynch delivers the wonderfully thrilling tale of an audacious criminal and his band of confidence tricksters. Set in a fantastic city pulsing with the lives of decadent nobles and daring thieves, here is a story of adventure, loyalty, and survival that is one part "Robin Hood", one part Ocean's Eleven, and entirely enthralling...

An orphan's life is harsh — and often short — in the island city of Camorr, built on the ruins of a mysterious alien race. But born with a quick wit and a gift for thieving, Locke Lamora has dodged both death and slavery, only to fall into the hands of an eyeless priest known as Chains — a man who is neither blind nor a priest.

A con artist of extraordinary talent, Chains passes his skills on to his carefully selected "family" of orphans — a group known as the Gentlemen Bastards. Under his tutelage, Locke grows to lead the Bastards, delightedly pulling off one outrageous confidence game after another. Soon he is infamous as the Thorn of Camorr, and no wealthy noble is safe from his sting.

Passing themselves off as petty thieves, the brilliant Locke and his tightly knit band of light-fingered brothers have fooled even the criminal underworld's most feared ruler, Capa Barsavi. But there is someone in the shadows more powerful — and more ambitious — than Locke has yet imagined.

Known as the Gray King, he is slowly killing Capa Barsavi's most trusted men — and using Locke as a pawn in his plot to take control of Camorr's underworld. With a bloody coup under way threatening to destroy everyone and everything that holds meaning in his mercenary life, Locke vows to beat the Gray King at his own brutal game — or die trying...


Kaja over at Of Dragons and Hearts is doing a readalong of The Gentlemen Bastards series, and I decided to jump in. I already owned the book because I meant to participate in the readalong back when Kritika at Snowflakes and Spider Silk had one last July. Obviously that never happened, but this was the perfect opportunity to redeem myself!

My Take

So, a few things about me and my reading tastes before I start out with this review (they’re relevant to the review, I swear). I used to love epic fantasy and sci-fi when I was younger. Robin Hobb was my ultimate favorite, but I also loved The Wheel of Time series in all its huge, epic glory. But somewhere along the line my attention span apparently lessened – I swear, having children has sucked brain cells right out of my head because I just no longer have the ability to focus when reading long, detailed descriptions of what all the characters are wearing and the bustling town – even though I know those details are fantastic and add layers upon layers of depth to the book. (I also used to LOVE classics when I was a teenager, and I can’t bring myself to read those anymore either, so …) Sometimes I wish I was a re-reader because I think I might be able to appreciate those details better upon a re-read when my brain isn’t clamoring to just know what happened. Anyway, that’s my disclaimer. Nowadays, when I read epic fantasy (just one or two books a year, typically), that colors my reading experience, so I have to explain it right from the start.

Now on to my actual review.

What I loved:

  • The gorgeous writing. There is no question that Scott Lynch is a genius writer. The language in this book isn’t flowery or pretentious (in fact, sometimes it’s downright crass – these are very real street characters), but Lynch always paints a vivid picture and he does it in a way that makes me want to read and re-read his phrases, just to experience them again (well, except for those descriptions – but I already explained that that’s my own issue).
  • The Gentleman Bastards. This is one of those cases where the friendships were the star of the book, and the relationship between The Gentleman Bastards (Locke’s group of thieving friends) is just utterly engaging and fantastic. Lynch managed to have me completely rooting for this group of morally questionable men – and hoping that their schemes worked out in their favor. Honestly, I barely even stopped to realize that I was rooting for the bad guys (since there were much more villainous characters to compare them to – The Gentleman Bastards at least had a code you could somewhat respect). Every character in this book was incredibly well-drawn, especially the Bastards – Bug was particularly easy to love, being the youngest of the group. He eagerly wanted to please and wasn’t afraid to put himself in harm’s way to do it. His utter faith in their little band of men and his enthusiasm and complete dedication to the group were pretty much adorable.
  • Locke Lamora. Locke is easily one of the most complex characters I’ve ever read. He is a genius when it comes to conning people, and yet you have to love his intelligence, his sense of loyalty and his unique moral code. Locke isn’t a perfect hero by any means, but his flaws make him that much more accessible. You can’t help but desperately want him to succeed, whether his intent is conning someone, saving people or getting revenge for the heinous acts against him (and there are some).
  • Tangled web. The actual plot of this book is, again, incredibly complex and nuanced. Locke’s group of men is part of a crime syndicate of sorts, and he reports to the Capa. But he manages to mostly fly under the radar – the Capa doesn’t realize what Locke’s group is actually capable of (or how much money they bring in). When a new power comes into play, Locke is no longer able to stay on the sidelines and he’s forced to play along with a dangerous plan – Locke has to use all his wits to stay alive, much less outsmart the men who want to use him.

The negatives:

  • Too much description sometimes (for me). I already explained this up at the top of my review, so I won’t go into it much more here. This is a “me” issue, and not really a negative for the book – but it does put a slight damper on my personal reading experience and brings my overall rating down, so I have to mention it.
  • The woven story. Again, this is pretty much just a “me” issue. Lynch weaves the story of Locke’s (and sometimes Jean’s) history in with the present, which I loved at the beginning of the book. It gave us glimpses into how Locke became such a genius thief and con man, but still allowed the story in the present to move forward. But I have to confess that toward the end of the book, when the action was really picking up in the present, I sometimes wanted to rush through the flashbacks to get back to the current action. (Again, that impatience rearing its ugly head!)

If you’re already a fan of epic fantasy, you need to read this one – it’s bound to be a five star read for you. While it doesn’t have as much magic as some other fantasies I’ve read, Lynch makes up for that with a richly imagined setting and an engaging plot (the story of Locke’s past reminded me a lot of Oliver Twist, which I loved.) And Lynch’s writing is just plain fantastic. Overall, I give this book 4/5 stars.

About the Author

Scott LynchI was born in St. Paul, Minnesota on April 2, 1978, the first of three brothers. I’ve lived in the Minneapolis/St. Paul area my entire life; currently, just across the border in Wisconsin, about half an hour east of the Twin Cities.

The Lies of Locke Lamora, my first novel, was bought by Simon Spanton at Orion Books in August, 2004. Prior to that I had just about every job you usually see in this sort of author bio– dishwasher, busboy, waiter, web designer, office manager, prep cook, and freelance writer. I trained in basic firefighting at Anoka Technical College in 2005, and became a volunteer firefighter in June of that year.

In 2007 The Lies of Locke Lamora was a World Fantasy Award finalist.

In 2008 I received the Sydney J. Bounds Best Newcomer Award from the British Fantasy Society.

In 2010, I lost a marriage but gained a cat, a charming ball of ego and fuzz known as Muse (Musicus Maximus Butthead Rex I).

My partner, the lovely and critically acclaimed SF/F writer Elizabeth Bear, lives in Massachusetts.

Author Links:
 photo iconwebsite-32x32_zps1f477f69.png  photo icongoodreads32_zps60f83491.png  photo icontwitter-32x32_zpsae13e2b2.png 


26 responses to “The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch – Readalong Review

  1. I was supposed to participate in this readalong AND Kritika’s readalong too Nicole but neither ended up working out for me 🙁 I vow to read this one in 2016!! You know me and my epic fantasy obsession so I just know I’ll love this one! Just reading about the things you did enjoy, like the writing and the charachers have me sold even more – and I know the descriptions will be fine by me 😀 Lovely review as always!

    Micheline @ Lunar Rainbows Reviews recently posted: Top Ten Tuesday #33
  2. I was glad to read your review of this! I enjoyed this book, although I didn’t love it completely. It’s a great, exciting read though, and Locke is so much fun to read about. I agree with your issues with it though – I wonder if it was a little shorter, if it would have improved the flow of the story. And not taken away from the complexity!

  3. I might join in the discussion for 2016. I have met your spouse and he led me here. I am a book buying and reading addict at the age of 48. My spouse hates to read. I use to be on wordpress but got off of it so give me time so that my blogger book site gets up to date – hope to connect and share. Jackie has listed you on her blog on the bottom, while playing around with the new site that is one day old.

    • Yes, you should definitely join us for the discussion challenge! My husband mentioned you last night and I thought it was so funny that he’d met another book blogger so close by – I was hoping you’d stop by the blog so I could “meet” you too! 🙂

  4. I’m really glad you liked it, Nicole! 🙂 Ha, YES, Locke is definitely one of the highlights of this book for me. And I get what you’re saying about the descriptions – his worldbuilding is so complex and intricate it’s sometimes a bit heavy. As far as I remember, this doesn’t go away in the sequels (as often happens in other fantasies where the author establishes the world in the first book and then focuses on action in the others) because each one is set in a different city (Tal Verrar for Red Seas and Karthain for Republic).
    I hope you’ll continue with the read-along and that you’ll enjoy the sequels! 🙂 I already added your link to my review post and the master post for the read-along. Thanks for participating!

    • I know that those types of descriptions add to the story – I know that in my head – but while I’m reading I tend to zone out on them a bit (or – ahem – skim). It does kind of amaze me, though, that I had a better attention span for that sort of thing as a teenager. If ANYONE likes to describe things it’s Robert Jordan – and I loved his books! When along the way did my brain turn into swiss cheese?

  5. I read this book a long time ago. I remember enjoying, but I think you’re right, the descriptions might be a little overdone. All I remember was enjoying the story, but that it took me forever to read it, compared to others books of that size. At the time, I don’t know that I knew exactly what it was. I wasn’t blogging at the time. I’ve got the audiobook and I plan to revisit it. I also want to continue the series to see where Locke goes. I just really liked him as a character. Like you said, he wasn’t perfect, but I liked him anyway. Great review. You’ve made me even more excited to get back into this series.

    Melanie Simmons @mlsimmons recently posted: In the Company of Wolves Audiobook by Paige Tyler (REVIEW)
    • You should join the readalong! That will motivate you to keep going with the series. I think Kaja is planning to read book two and review it on February 15th, so that might give you time to listen to the audio for both books one and two if you wanted to. 🙂

  6. I got this one at NYC Comic Con in 2014 and was super excited for it. I’ve been putting it off for awhile now. I definitely need to pick it up soon!!

  7. I’m really curious about this one, somehow books about thieves always spark my interest! I have been wanting to read more epic fantasy for a while. I have been intimidated for a very long time by all those big books, but since I have managed to read almost all the Game of Thrones books that are out I think I will manage 😉
    I get your problem with books with a lot of description though! For a very long time I had also a problem with picking up books that would take me really long to read. I was already busy with a lot of other things in my life and because of that I just didn’t have the patience anymore so sit down and really relax and not think about all the things I still have to do, but really focus on the book. Lately I’ve been a lot better at giving books my full attention. I think I have more patience for long and descriptive books if I read novellas or graphic novels/comics in between.

  8. So, I had completely forgotten that the Gentlemen Bastard were even bad guys until I just read this XD I knew they were at the begging – they are thieves stealing- but because I fell love with the Gentlemen Bastard crew, and what they actually did with everything stole, they didn’t feel like “bad” guys to me.

    But I am HUGE fan of the complex plots, and I love the descriptions that come with epic fantasy. I’ll admit, many times the amount of descriptions can get very tiresome for me, but with Lynch… I could read his prose all day long 🙂

    I did really enjoy those interludes at the end of each chapter, and actually really looked forward to them. Though, when things were finally going down at the end, didn’t really want to leave that action either!

Leave a Reply

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.