What Do You Think of Goodreads’ New Look? Let’s Discuss!

Posted August 5, 2016 by Nicole @ Feed Your Fiction Addiction in Let's Discuss / 53 Comments


So, Goodreads just rolled out some new changes, and I have to say that I’m liking them. The new look and feel seems easier to navigate somehow – easier to find the things I’m really looking for. I think, honestly, just has to do with the fact that they made the images bigger. It’s amazing to me how much of a different feel that gives the site.

The biggest difference is that I now notice my friends’ reviews more – I like that I was able customize this list so that it would show reviews only (I really don’t need to see every time someone adds a book to their TBR shelf) and Top Friends only. (BUT I can easily switch to All Friends to see more!)

Since I’m paying more attention to the lists now, I decided to go through and edit my Top Friends a bit so that I’d be sure to see reviews from those of you I’m friends with. I basically only kept people as Top Friends if I interact with them on at least a semi-regular basis OR if I know that they like the same books I do (or I just love their reviews). Going through the list made me realize that I have lots of random people I’ve never heard of on there and I was missing some of my best blogger friends!

I wish that Goodreads made editing this list a little easier, though. First of all, it would be nice if you could see people’s websites right from the Friends screen – For the most part, I know everyone’s names, but sometimes the person’s Goodreads name might just be “Sarah.” Um, I know a few of those! Plus, as I was going through the numerous pages of friends, I would see people on there twice sometimes. The most annoying was probably the fact that if I deleted a friend completely (which I only did for people who had basically no books on their Goodreads shelves), it would take me out of edit mode and I’d have to go back up to the top of the page and turn it back on. Not user friendly!

What do you guys think? Do you like Goodreads’ new look, or is it all the same to you? Any new features I should be trying out?  I want to know!




53 responses to “What Do You Think of Goodreads’ New Look? Let’s Discuss!

  1. I’m not so fond of the large boxes with all the book information. I wish there were an option to collapse these so I could scroll through more updates more quickly. Or you could see the book info by hovering over the title.

    I also sort of miss seeing more than one recommendation at a time based on books I’m currently reading. I seldom took up any of them, but they were kind of fun to look at.

    Otherwise, I’m okay with it. The changes to Bloglovin’ are another matter — ugh!

    • Funny that the thing that I like best is your least favorite feature. I find my eye being drawn to those updates a lot more and I feel like it invites me to interact more. I liked and commented on several friends’ updates and it just seemed so much easier to me somehow (even though I don’t think the process itself was any easier).

      Now I had to jump over to Bloglovin’ to see what was happening over there – I swear I was just on it yesterday and it looked normal. I guess the jury’s out for me about whether or not I like those changes. I’ll have to let you know once I try it out for awhile!

      • On BL they’ve made a two-column feed and staggered the posts so your eye has to jump back and forth. That’s the main thing I don’t like now, but they’ve been making changes for a while that bugged me — mixing in more ads, removing the direct link to saved posts, etc. This is just the last straw for me.

        With Goodreads, I think I just have different preferences than most people! And I am sure I”ll get used to the new look. And I think you’re right that it invites more liking and commenting. Maybe I will get more into that than I have been.

        • I’ve been playing around with Bloglovin’, and it might be possible to fix the 2 columns thing. Near the top of the feed page, there is a button with three dots. It’s right next to the “Mark All As Read” button. Click the three dots and select “List View (Small Images)” instead of grid view. Hopefully the three dots button shows up for you. Since the changes, my computer struggles to load Bloglovin’.

          Aj @ Read All The Things! recently posted: July Wrap-Up
  2. I’m liking the new look. I haven’t played around with it too much, but I like that the Goodreads challenge is near the top now. It’s much easier to see where you are at and the last books you read or added to your to-read list. It does let me view my feed a lot easier too.


    ShootingStarsMag recently posted: Textbook Amy Krouse Rosenthal
  3. I had no idea you could edit it to just show reviews? I’m going to have to go do some exploring. My main issue is with the way they show friends’ likes and comments. Like, if one of my friends likes someone else’s status, the status just shows up on my feed and looks like every other status. So then I get confused and think it’s a status for one of my friends when it’s actually a stranger. So I foresee myself accidentally liking a lot of strangers’ statuses and reviews in the near future lol.

    Kristen @ Metaphors and Moonlight recently posted: Book Review: Machinations (Machinations Book 1) by Hayley Stone
    • I don’t see that, so I think that also would be fixed by customizing your feed. You can probably figure this out easily, but here’s how: Right above the Updates (on the right) it says Customize with a little gear next to it. Click on the gear and you can choose what things you want to see in the feed. Right now I have mine set to Reviews only and Top Friends only (don’t worry, you’re one of them!), but I like that I can easily toggle this to see other things too!

  4. Jen

    I think I’m the odd duck here because I never really go on the Home Page. I get daily e-mails, for all of my Goodreads friends, that lists all of their reviews and books added. So it doesn’t matter if I don’t go on Goodreads for a few days, I am still catch up on everything through my emails. Honestly, I had no clue there was a change lol. But I’m glad to hear that you like it. Now I’m going to have to click Home next time I’m on there!

      • Jen

        The bookmark I have to go on Goodreads is my page and not the home page so that’s probably another reason I’m not on the main page. But I click through their daily emails a ridiculous amount of times to comment and like reviews. Plus that always leads me to adding so many books to my to-read list that sound amazing. 🙂 So I always end up going to just those reviews, book pages or my page and that’s about it. But for posting reviews, I have UBB auto post for me from the blog to Goodreads. I love that add-on! 🙂

  5. I think some people’s biggest problem is that it’s new. Most people don’t do well with change. I’m sure once they’ve adapted everything will work out smoothly. (And yes I’m including myself in this). How many times have we grumbled over Facebook’s changes and then we get used to them and it’s like nothing ever happened (at least some of them)?

  6. I didn’t notice it until one of the members of my goodreads group mentioned it, but I like it and find myself going to my homepage now just to see whats up instead of going to my groups bookmarked page.

  7. I’ve had this update for a while now, because I switched to it when it was in beta mode so I’m quite accustomed to it and I still like it. Especially how it looks. I’m a sucker for look and this is just pleasing to my eye. I also like how they changed the section with my currently-reading books. 🙂

  8. I completely freaked out when Goodreads changed because Bloglovin’ just changed, too, and I wasn’t a fan of those changes. I couldn’t use Bloglovin’ for about 2 weeks because it was so broken. I rely on Bloglovin’ A LOT, so this was slightly devastating. I think the Goodreads changes will be cool when I play around with it more. Right now, I’m seeing a lot of stuff in my feed I don’t care about.

    Aj @ Read All The Things! recently posted: July Wrap-Up
    • I actually hadn’t seen the Bloglovin’ changes until after I wrote this – they must have been rolling out the changes in stages like Goodreads did. I think the Bloglovin’ changes will take more getting used to, but I’m reserving judgment for now.

  9. Tonyalee

    I honesty think goodreads has such more of use then what I use it for. Maybe I should go on and see all of what it can do. Anyway, I actually like the new look!

  10. I don’t spend a lot of time on my homepage, but my first reaction when I saw the new design was that I really liked it. It seems so much cleaner than it was before!

    I have never really used GR as a social networking site and don’t tend to interact much with others, aside from reading reviews if it’s a book I’m already interested in.In some cases I will post a small review or update, but generally I rate books and review them elsewhere… I may have to look at changing that up.

    Michelle recently posted: Stacking the Shelves #7
  11. Oh I was using that “only see top-friends in the feed” mode before in the old site! So I think it’s always been there. ? I definitely utilise that because I have like 2,000 friends and IDEK who they are half the time ahhahah. Ahem. I only have about a dozen in my top-friends list. :’)
    Aaaanyway…I unfortunately do not like the new look. Like I’ll get used to it, eventually, but I find it’s to cluttered and I hate that it puts the book synopsis up on EVERY SINGLE STATUS UPDATE. Too much! It distracts from what the status update even is.?
    I just wish they’d start making some useful changes…like letting you log multiple years on books for re-reads and adding half stars.?

    • How funny that the feature’s been there all along – I actually kind of wondered about that, but I never noticed it before the friend reviews became so much more prominent. I definitely notice them a lot more now and it encourages me to interact with them more. I do see what you’re saying about the synopsis, though. It would be nice if there was an option to show or hide those. And, of course, we all wish for half stars, but I’ve given up on that one as a pipe dream. 🙂

  12. Joycedale

    I usual use the app and I’m hardley ever on my homepage in a browser but I do like that my challenge is posted near the top now.

  13. I’m not sure what I think about it yet. I honestly never used the homepage much previously, and I’m not sure if I’ll use it more now or not.

    I had the Top Friends thing before, in that I only get e-mail updates on Top Friends when they publish a new review. Didn’t want to get spammed with reviews from tons of people I never actually spoke with.

    One thing I did notice that amused me though. The section on recommended books? Mine said that since I had read and liked an Amish Cozy Mystery, I might also be interested in this random sci-fi romance. I’m… not sure how those 2 go together? *lol* I like sci-fi, and have nothing against romance in books, but suggesting that because of an Amish mystery was weird!

  14. I don’t know yet lol. Changes are hard for me haha – it seems like things switched. I’m used to them being on the right, and they are now on the left. And I’m still getting confused. But yes, the bigger design is good, and you can find stuff much easier.

  15. At first, I was all like “what the hell” But a few days later and I like it. I agree that it makes stuff easier to find. I don’t have the problem with friends, though. I put up a question. It was a simple how did you find me? Tere is no wrong answers, but you fail to put an answer I am not adding you. This cut-down TREMODSOLY on the spam accounts.

  16. Right at this moment, I don’t like it. But I am sure I will come to love it. The reason I don’t like it right now is because I have such an aversion to change. I didn’t know you could make those changes to your Goodreads page though. I may have to do that.

  17. I’ve been using this new layout since it was in beta, so I’m pretty used to it. I like everything except the three columns. IMO you only have three columns if you’re trying to find places for all your clutter. I don’t like how smooshed the centre column looks.

  18. I like the new look! I am usually all weird with change, and resistant, and all that jazz, but I actually REALLy like this, it works for me. I do need to go and play around with it a bit more, but so far I am a fan. I went through a while back and tried to remove some of my not-actually-top friends, so that helps too- I love that I can see MY stuff AND everyone else’s- it’s like an added bonus (because let’s be real, I usually come to see my own stuff, and this is a nice perk!) I am trying top friends only now, but I also need to make sure that all my ACTUAL top friends are listed as such! Great post, I hadn’t even looked to see that I could change that stuff, so thanks!

    Shannon @ It Starts at Midnight recently posted: Review: Tumbling by Caela Carter
  19. I completely agree about it needing to be easier to edit friends! I like the new look now that I’ve gotten used to it, but I’m annoyed they changed some things that don’t seem to matter one way or the other, like the location of the books I’m reading widget. It doesn’t matter to me where it is, but I was used to it at the original location!

  20. I don’t use the social aspect of Goodreads at all. Maybe if I customize it so it isn’t just a list of random people adding to their lists, I would like it more.

    • Hey, Carrie! Did you get my email that you won the July Discussion Challenge giveaway? It’s been three days and I haven’t heard back from you, but I don’t want to give your prize to someone else just yet! Check your SPAM and if you don’t see it, shoot me an email (you can get to it from the sidebar of my blog!).

Leave a Reply

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.